Bay Island Homes for Sale


Located on Siesta Key in Sarasota FL, Bay Island is the epitome of luxurious island living. This beautiful waterfront community offers very quick access to the ICW, Sarasota Bay, and the clear blue waters of the Gulf of Mexico. Bay Island homes for sale are situated at the north end of the island, allowing for dazzling views of the Sarasota skyline as well as the Bay. This wonderful community is a great place to call home!

Bay Island Homes for Sale siesta keyDiscover More About Bay Island Homes for Sale

One of the many wonderful benefits of living in Bay Island FL real estate is that you can enjoy convenient access to Downtown Sarasota and all its excellent amenities. Residents are just a quick drive away from downtown’s fantastic selection of shops, restaurants, art galleries, museums and theaters. The community also offers a close proximity to Westfield Southgate, Westfield Sarasota Square, and the shopping, cafes and restaurants of Southside Village and the Siesta Drive area.

Opportunities in outdoor recreation are readily available near Bay Island homes for sale. The community has direct Gulf access, which will greatly appeal to prospective buyers with a love of fishing. One can find many spectacular species of fish in these gorgeous waters. In addition, sailing enthusiasts can bring their boat to the Bay. Plus, the world famous Siesta Key Beach is situated just five minutes to the south of Bay Island. Residents can enjoy fishing, snorkeling, kayaking, boating, parasailing, swimming, or just relaxing while taking in the the amazing views.

Bay Island FL real estate possesses some of the most stylish and distinguished architectural designs in Sarasota. Prospective buyers will find plenty of options, including bungalows dating back to the 1950s, quaint 1930 style cottages and sprawling modern estates. These homes also boast some of the greatest water access in the area, with deep entrance ramps for large yachts, sail boats, and party barges. Current home prices range from approximately $600,000 to well over $8 million.

If you would like to learn more about available homes for sale in Bay Island, please contact Sarasota FL Realtor Nicki Conway for an amazing home buying experience!

Advanced Options